Independent Catholic resourceNot affiliated with Catholic Answers (catholic.com)
THECatholic AnswersFaith. Understood.
CATHOLIC TOPICS

Atheism & Rationalism

38 articles from the existing collection.

God & Faith9 min read

Is Belief Necessary for Future Eternal Happiness?

The Catholic Church holds that faith is a foundational element for achieving eternal happiness, which is understood as the beatific vision—union with God in heaven. Faith is a supernatural gift that enables individuals to assent to God’s revelation, particularly as transmitted through Scripture and Tradition. The Letter to the H…

Other Christians & Religions1 min read

I don’t agree with any of these priestly claims. Anyway, the search’ light of modern science is gradually breaking them up.

The searchlight of science is doing good work in destroying superstition, and showing the fallacies of false religions which are due to the natural instinct of religion in all men, and the ignorance of the true religion revealed by God. But sound science is doing a great work for the Catholic Church and helping many towards her.…

God & Faith1 min read

I am a materialist and cannot admit miracles, alleged or otherwise.

You are not really a materialist. Neither thought nor love are material things, yet you believe in them. Your statement, too, conflicts with reason. When you say “alleged or otherwise” you can only mean “alleged or not merely alleged but historically true.” The miracles in favor of revelation are historically certain.

The Church1 min read

Will not the Catholic Church have to part with many of its doctrines in deference to modern thought, if it is to last till the end of time?

No. The Catholic Church is living to-day precisely because she has ever refused to part with her doctrines, which are the doctrines of Christ. The heresies of the centuries parted with doctrines of Christian faith in deference to human opinions, and they died in turn through the ages. Protestantism is dying visibly to-day. Any a…

Last Things & Salvation1 min read

You have distinguished between the body and the soul of man, the soul being a spirit. Yet how can a man belong to the material and the spiritual worlds at once? They exclude each other.

A material world cannot be a spiritual world, nor can a spiritual world be a material world. But the two can exist simultaneously, even as in one man’s head we have material brains and spiritual thoughts. We cannot say that a man’s material brains so fill a man’s head that they leave no room for thought. Even in purely physical …

Sacraments & Worship1 min read

Deut. XIII. says that a husband should stone his own wife to death if she try to persuade him to join her in idolatry. “Well now,” says Ingersoll, “I hate a god of that kind, and I would not do it.” Did God make a mistake, or is Deut. wrong?

Ingersoll, as usual, makes many mistakes. Firstly, he forgot the theocratic nature of the nation of the Jews at that time. God was the direct ruler of the Jews, and idolatry was going over to the king’s enemies, and an act of treason, even in the temporal order. And God has full rights over life and death. Secondly, if Ingersoll…

God & Faith1 min read

God treated the Jews unfairly. It must have been difficult to comprehend the teachings of Christ, and He offered them no material benefits

God did not treat the Jews unfairly. They had every opportunity given them to recognize the truth. Christ offered them the evidence of many miracles in the material order and before their eyes. They could not deny these miracles, but in their bad will ascribed them to the devil. Christ, as promised, came to offer eternal spiritu…

God & Faith1 min read

Your dogmas must cramp the free play of a man’s intelligence.

They no more cramp a man’s intelligence than an excellent telescope diminishes his power of sight. They give additional light upon the most important matters. For example, the dogma that there is a hell saves me from the mistake of thinking that there is no hell—surely a vital matter. And the more a man uses his intelligence in …

Other Christians & Religions1 min read

Christ gave us the religion we need, and we need a religion of healing.

We do not. We need the religion of Christ. The poor, whether by lack of health or wealth, have always existed, and always will exist, according to Christ. He healed some people to prove His mission. But by no means did He heal all whom He knew to be sick. Had he done so, there would not have been a single sick person left in the…

God & Faith2 min read

It is strange that two highly intellectual men should be affected so differently, you being attracted to join the Catholic Church, McCabe impelled to leave it.

It is not strange. Intellectual attainments have really little to do with it, in the ultimate analysis. Brains alone cannot bring a man to Christian truth, and brains alone will not keep him in it. Christ did not say, “Come to Me, all ye intellectual people, and I will refresh you.” If knowledge of religious truth and faith in i…

God & Faith1 min read

We rationalists can never become Catholics.

But rational men can do so. If you are not a Catholic, it is not sound reasoning that keeps you outside the Church. Defective information, mere want of thought, prejudice, moral cowardice, heredity, environment, and a hundred other factors may conspire to keep men outside the Catholic Church. But sound reason never does. Sound r…

God & Faith1 min read

Would you question his honesty of purpose?

Yes. McCabe has sought to make money and court popularity by reviling the Church he quitted. He claims to know history, yet quotes as facts things he must know to be untrue—calumnies which Ernest Renan, as good a rationalist as McCabe, had refuted twenty years before McCabe rehashed them. Though he claims to be an unbeliever in …

Other Christians & Religions1 min read

Is the practice of religion necessary?

Yes. God has definite rights which no man is justified in ignoring. Moreover God definitely commands you to adore and serve Him. “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God . . . this is the first and greatest commandment.” A man with no religion, who never worships God, never says a prayer to Him, is far from fulfilling this commandment …

KNOWLEDGE SHARED. FAITH STRENGTHENED.

Keep the door open.

Your optional contribution helps keep these resources free to read.

Support this independent site